Skip to content
OnySnow Studios
← Opallite: the notes

Fan Art as a LegalRevenue Line.

Studios spend heavily policing fan art. My plan proposes a marketplace where fans sell it legally and the rights holder takes a share. A proposal with numbers attached, not a deal.

Fans draw the characters they love. The people who own those characters can ignore it or send takedowns, and the artists in the middle never know which. My plan proposes a third option: give fan art a legitimate marketplace and let the rights holder take a cut.

The proposed split

The plan calls this its "fan art advocacy position". Chapter 8 sets the marketplace split:

  • 70-80% to the fan artist
  • 10-15% to the original IP owner, "facilitated through partnerships"
  • 10-15% to the platform

Minimum prices stop fan art being sold for pennies: $50 for an original, $30 for a limited edition, $20 for an open edition. The logic is that each side gets something. The artist earns legally, the owner earns and gains engagement, and the platform takes its fee.

AI-generated concept render of a gallery space, not a photograph of a built product.
AI-generated concept render of a gallery space, not a photograph of a built product.

The studio's side of the ledger

Chapter 7.3 argues from what a major rights holder spends today. It lists legal monitoring at $5-10 million a year, DMCA and takedown processes at $3-6 million, and "lost merchandising opportunities" of $50-100 million across the industry. Those are the plan's estimates. I have not traced them to a published source.

It then walks through one case, "Major Entertainment Franchise", with no name and no source, so I treat it as an illustration:

  • previous annual enforcement budget: $1.2 million
  • platform revenue share: $1.8 million (a Year 3 projection)
  • enforcement cost reduction: $0.9 million
  • net benefit: $2.7 million a year

The arithmetic holds. $1.8M plus $0.9M is $2.7M, and $0.9M saved out of $1.2M is 75%, inside the plan's claimed 70-85% enforcement saving. The inputs are assumptions.

The size of the bet

Chapter 8 projects a fan art market of $150-220 million by Year 5 once minimum prices apply, growing 45-60% a year, with $15-30 million a year in platform revenue. Chapter 7 gives $120-180 million and $12-25 million for the same thing. The plan also expects 25-35% of existing fan artists to move to a legitimate platform, which it counts as 25,000-40,000 creators gaining a legal income, and its base-case five-year scenario puts fan art at $18 million in Year 5.

My own chart scripts add a third number: they treat fan art as a market of about $8.5 billion with a 12% capture rate. That is gross sales volume, a different quantity from the plan's commission revenue. Three sources, three framings. Reconciling them is on my list.

Why a studio might say no

The plan rates IP-owner resistance a medium-high probability in Years 1-2, falling to low-medium by Year 5, with an impact that is "potentially significant if major IP holders resist participation." A precedent-setting legal case is a risk of its own. The mitigation is to start with progressive rights holders, show them the economics and keep the legal design conservative.

That design has a name, the "Fan Art Safe Harbor Initiative": legal framework, rights-management technology and compliance monitoring. The plan prices the legal and partnership work around it at $5-8 million across Years 1-2.

It matches Chapter 6's sequencing of partners by company age, early, middle, then late, so that each stage proves the next. The same chapter treats exclusive arrangements as an exception, only when they give a real advantage, and asks for "fair compensation" with particular emphasis on artist compensation.

The Future of Art | Work slide from the pitch deck, with its "No AI Art" pillar.
The Future of Art | Work slide from the pitch deck, with its "No AI Art" pillar.

What would make it real

No studio has agreed to any of this, and my files show no talks. Three things would change that: a rights holder willing to look at the split, a lawyer's reading of the framework, and a pilot with one fandom and one willing studio. Until then it is a proposal I think is worth testing, with every figure above a target.

Responses

0

I read every note before it goes up. No account needed.

I'm open to creative technical project management, founding teams, and agentic AI engineering and research. I read everything that comes in, and I answer.

onysnowstudios@gmail.comLinkedIn →

Resume