Designing five themes where status never relies on colour
The Journalism Workbench, my private investigation app, has five complete themes and one rule none of them may change: a status is always a shape and a word, never a colour alone. The redesign research measured why. In every theme, the colours for Supported and Disputed are too close for a red-green colour-blind reader to tell apart.
On 10 October I decided the app should have a theme setting with entirely different looks, including one of my own: gritty, rainy, bokeh. That became Rain Noir, built from my portfolio's effects. The research then built out five complete themes and checked every one of them.
The five are Case Night (the default), Rain Noir, Archive, Forest Ledger and Indigo Clarity, and each has a one-line mood. Case Night is “the newsroom after dark: calm blue, warm cream paper, one amber lamp.” Rain Noir is “a city at night through a wet window; gritty and cinematic, on calm dry surfaces.” Archive is a records room, Forest Ledger a quiet library for long sessions, and Indigo Clarity “clear and steady”, with almost no motion.
Every surface is dark but none is black
I wanted dark colours and never black. My own portfolio breaks that: its ground, #0E0906, is so close to black that, in the research's words, it “breaks ‘never black’ in spirit.” So for Rain Noir every surface was lifted by about 0.045 in lightness, keeping its hue and chroma (how saturated it is), giving a ground of #18120F. The portfolio's darker value stays only inside photographs behind glass.
The research also measured its own earlier drawings. In Case Night, the mockups' muted text measured 4.22:1 on the selected surface, below the AA line of 4.5:1 that the WCAG accessibility guidelines ask of normal text. It was lifted to #C6BBA5, which measures 4.66:1. The chapter's banner counts five themes and no contrast failures; these figures are the research's own, computed by a script, and this page does not recompute them.
Supported and Disputed are nearly the same colour
The two colours that matter most in an investigation tool are the one for Supported and the one for Disputed. The research measured how different they are from each other, where a ratio of 1:1 would mean identical. In Case Night the ratio is 1.13:1, in Rain Noir 1.47, Archive 1.56, Forest Ledger 1.28 and Indigo Clarity 1.33.
The research concluded that “a red-green colour-blind reader could not tell them apart by colour”, which is why the ✓ and ✕ shapes and words are required.
So every theme only recolours a fixed set of shapes and words. Supported is a ✓ in a filled circle with the word SUPPORTED. Disputed is a ✕ in a diamond with the word DISPUTED. Not yet shown is a hollow dashed ring.
Red Flags, the warning signs the app's rules raise, have three levels, each three bars with a word: ▮▯▯ Faint, ▮▮▯ Strong, ▮▮▮ Textbook. Confidence uses dots, so it can never be mistaken for a flag level. In Forest Ledger, Supported is sky blue and deliberately not green, because green “would sink into the ground” and “also means money in this subject”.
A theme is tried on your own case before it is kept
The theme gallery is meant to be tried on a real case rather than a sample. Pointing at a card redraws the current screen inside a before-and-after divider, and nothing is saved until you press Keep. By 19 October the project's build list also records a “Make your own” theme: change any of 17 colours, with 21 pairs checked for contrast as you go, and a save that is refused by naming the failing pair.
Still open: the fonts
The decision record that bundles the themes' fonts on the computer is still marked Proposed: I have not accepted it yet.
Sources and notes (5)
- Redesign research — the notes this was written from: theme chapter, contrast figures
- Redesign notes — the notes this was written from
- Mockup build list — the notes this was written from
- ADR-0008: theme fonts — the notes this was written from
- Theme gallery mockup — the mockup the piece shows
Journalism WorkbenchAll 12 parts →
