Teaching the Workbench’s red flags with real cases
The Workbench's red-flag rules, the warning signs it raises in a case, are tested on demo cases built from public records. Structuring (splitting payments into smaller ones), shell chains and sanctions each have a small real case. The ownership-loop rule, which flags two companies that own each other, has a gap: the big 1MDB demo case contains no loop, so the rule never fires there.
The first answer was a small real case for that one rule, built from a Bermuda court judgment. I turned it down, because a whole demo case built to show one indicator is poor design, and it was removed as a case on 11 October. Its record is kept aside for the tutorial instead.
A Bermuda judgment that describes a loop
The judgment is In the Matter of Jardine Strategic Holdings Limited, Supreme Court of Bermuda, 2021 Nos. 107-126, judgment of Hargun CJ on 12 November 2021, 37 pages, published on gov.bm and pinned by its SHA-256 fingerprint.
Two passages carry the loop. Page 3, paragraph 3: “Prior to the Amalgamation, amongst other interests in the Group, Jardine Matheson held, indirectly, approximately 84.9% of the shares in the Company.” Page 3, paragraph 5: “The Group's structure included a cross-holding structure between the two listed companies. The Company owned, directly and indirectly, 59.3% of the shares in Jardine Matheson.”
Around it the record holds Jardine Strategic's stakes in Hong Kong Land (50.4%), Dairy Farm (77.6%), Mandarin Oriental (79.5%) and Jardine Cycle & Carriage (75%), four dated events, claims and two leads. While it was still a case, it was loaded and the rules engine raised exactly one ownership-loop flag, naming both companies and nothing else.
The tutorial is planned as five real choices
The research for “Learning and help” records that nothing was built at the time. The plan has a first-run tutorial of five steps, each a real choice with buttons of equal weight and nothing pre-selected: theme and effects, outside lookups, research automation, private AI, then open the sample case or start your own.
It has progress dots, a Skip that is always visible, and every choice changeable later. It cites Zooniverse's advice: “keep your tutorial as short as possible”.
Next to it sits a practice mode of flip cards. The front is a sign as a short scene, such as a registered address shared with 212 other companies. The back gives the indicator, its level, the innocent explanations first, and the source.
A second idea is teach-back. The first time a reporter decides a To check item for an indicator, one skippable card for that indicator is shown first, so the method is learnt where it is used.
The catalogue is built but the practice cards are not
By 19 October, the catalogue of 42 areas in six families and the glossary were built. The practice cards were not: they need a store for review state, which is an open question.
The six families are the mockup's grouping and still wait on me. The guides themselves are content I have to write.
Two notes also differ on the case the tutorial teaches with. The research names a Kestrel SA and Harbour Nominees sample, labelled a teaching case, as the textbook, while the 11 October tutorial notes say the tutorial will be built on the 1MDB demo.
Sources and notes (6)
- In the Matter of Jardine Strategic Holdings Limited (Supreme Court of Bermuda, 12 Nov 2021) — the court's account of the cross-holding, quoted in the piece
- Zooniverse: getting started — advice to keep a tutorial as short as possible
- Tutorial notes — the notes this was written from
- Jardine record (documents.json) — the record kept for the tutorial, with the judgment's fingerprint
- Redesign research — the notes this was written from: Learning and help chapter
- Catalogue mockup — the mockup the piece shows
Journalism WorkbenchAll 12 parts →
