How do you test everything without having everything?
The Workbench handles documents, photographs, video, foreign-language judgments and money in six currencies, and a test case with three PDFs tests none of it. My answer was a demo case built from public records, holding 104 documents, with three small real cases for what it can’t cover.
The Workbench handles documents, photos, video, a podcast, foreign-language judgments, emails, spreadsheets and money in six currencies. A test case with three PDFs tests none of that, and on 11 October there was nothing better to test it with.
So I built demo cases, with three rules about what's allowed in them. Copyrighted material (news, press photographs, video, podcasts) is fetched when the case loads and never stored in the repository. Emails are rebuilt word for word from the filings and labelled as rebuilt. Rules the big case can't trigger get small real cases of their own.
What the 1MDB case holds
The 1MDB demo case, built only from public material, has 104 documents: 21 photographs as picture evidence with dates, a video and a podcast, 19 articles (six contradicting the official account), judgments from Malaysia, Switzerland and Singapore (some scanned, one in Malay, French and German ones), 15 rebuilt emails, and a spreadsheet of payments.
On top of the documents: 84 payments in six currencies, 21 places with coordinates, claims graded confirmed, rejected or disputed, 97 events and 37 red flags.
Three small cases for the rest
Three small real cases cover what 1MDB can't. United States v. Anise has 144 cash deposits kept under $10,000 (structuring). The Vekselberg shell network has six layers of ownership and a shared address. The Deripaska and Rusal sanctions notices cover sanctions.
Sources and notes (9)
- United States v. Anise: indictment (D.N.J.) — the small structuring case, 144 deposits under $10,000
- Vekselberg: verified civil forfeiture complaint (S.D.N.Y.) — the shell-network case
- Vekselberg: Tango seizure warrant affidavit — the shell-network case
- OFAC notice, Federal Register, 1 May 2018 — sanctions notice used in the Vekselberg and Deripaska cases
- Treasury letter to Congress on En+, Rusal and EuroSibEnergo — the Deripaska and Rusal case
- United States v. Low and Ng: indictment (E.D.N.Y.) — public record behind the 1MDB demo case
- United States v. M/Y Equanimity: forfeiture complaint — public record behind the 1MDB demo case
- Demo cases — the notes this was written from
- Demo case manifest — the notes this was written from
Journalism WorkbenchAll 12 parts →
